To recap: Kwame Anthony Appiah proposes three criteria for identifying current practices that future generations will condemn:
- The arguments against it have been around a while, had time to sink in and time to be refuted if they were going to be.
- The arguments for it tend to be arguments of convenience or necessity or tradition rather than arguments of rightness or genuine social benefit.
- Continuation of the practice relies on people just not thinking about it much.
In no particular order, here's the first one:
The U.S. Prison system
The harm is known and has been known for some time. I daresay you know the basics, even if you don’t know these exact numbers off the top of your head:
- 2.1 million people are in prison the US,
- while the US has 4 percent of the world’s population, it has 25 percent of the all the world’s prisoners.
The punishment prisoners face goes far beyond the judge’s sentence.
- 100,000 inmates are sexually abused every year.
- 25,000 are in isolation under conditions many psychologists say amounts to torture.
Criterion 1: The arguments against it have been around a while, had time to sink in and time to be refuted if they were going to be.
Check.
Criterion 2: The arguments for it tend to be arguments of convenience or necessity or tradition.
Check.
Critierion 3: Continuation of the practice relies on people just not thinking about it much.
Check.
* * * * *
This is part 4 of 7 of "The Future Will Judge Us"
Next: Part 5: "Industrial Meat: How Will Our Great-Grandkids Forgive Us?"
Previous: Part 3: "Three Criteria"
Beginning: Part 1: "What Were They Thinking?"
No comments:
Post a Comment